There has been a lot of criticism of American
Schools, K thru 12 and
college. Some things we ought to keep in
mind. The Catholics run very good
parochial schools at very reasonable costs.
We sent our three children to parochial schools and the experience was
good. The public schools should take
notes.
I did Framingham
public school up thru 9th grade and then Westtown
Friends School
and then college and finally the Air Force.
I had pretty good teachers all the way.
There were a couple of duds, Miss Waters and Miss Coyne, but the rest
were all fair to very good. But the best
teachers I had in all that time were in the Air Force. USAF ran Field Training Detachments (FTD) to
teach aircraft maintenance, airborne radar, jet engines, fire control, guided
missiles, instruments, electrical systems, lots of good stuff. The teachers of this stuff were really
good. They were just flight line
mechanics, pulled right off the flight line and run thru a three week “How to
teach FTD” course. None of them had ever
been to college. But they were
good. They knew their stuff, backward
and forward. Their classes were all teenage boys, who could be
troublesome. The FTD instructors never
had any trouble with student discipline.
The students all knew they had to pass the FTD courses in order to get
promoted from apprentices to journeymen, so an instructor’s invitation to a
troublesome student to leave the class was effective.
My take away from
the Air Force was two things. The
students had to know the material was essential, and the teacher had to know
the material cold.
Which to my mind
means prospective teachers ought to major in stuff they need to teach, like
English, history, mathematics, foreign language, physics, chemistry,
biology? Not “education”. My college roommate wanted to teach after
graduation so he majored in “education”.
He told me it was the most worthless, boring major imaginable, and he
only put up with it to get a job teaching in the public schools. After watching the FTD instructors do a super
job with just a three week “How to be an FTD instructor” course I can believe
that.
American education
would be better if we scrapped the “education” major entirely.