It has a great cast, Johnny Depp, Kate Winslet, Dustin Hoffman. It's set in Edwardian London, sets and costumes are superb. Charming London horse drawn cabs, equally charming turn of the century automobiles. The story is that of J.M. Barrie creating Peter Pan as a stage play on the London stage. Barrie is married, but for the duration of the movie, he neglects his wife, and hangs out with a charming widow and her four boys. All that said, the movie doesn't click.
First off, it suffers from the curse of the soundman, probably as bad as it gets. I could not hear the dialog. The actors whispered, spoke in thick dialect, and mumbled. No names were ever mentioned. I had to check IMDB this morning to learn the widow's stage name.
And it is slow moving. Takes forever to get to the point. Plot is weak. For instance, we never see how Barrie manages to bring such an unconventional play as Peter Pan to the stage. Is he independently wealthy and financed it himself? Is Barrie enormously effective in selling the concept to dubious theater owners and backers, kind of like Peter Jackson in our own time? something else? We never know. The nameless widow, comes down with something, and dies in the last reel. For no good reason I could see.
Too bad. It could have been cool.